Symphony No. 40 (Mozart)

Symphony in G minor
Symphony in G minor
No. 40
by W. A. Mozart
	Mozart c. 1783
Key	G minor
Catalogue	K. 550
Composed	1788
Movements	four

Symphony No. 40 in G minor, K. 550 was written by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart in 1788. It is sometimes referred to as the "Great G minor symphony", to distinguish it from the "Little G minor symphony", No. 25. The two are the only extant minor key among Mozart's symphonies.^[1]^{[nb 1]}

History

Composition

The date of completion of this symphony is known exactly, since Mozart in his mature years kept a full catalog of his completed works; he entered the 40th Symphony into it on 25 July 1788.^[2] Work on the symphony occupied an exceptionally productive period of just a few weeks during which time he also completed the 39th and 41st symphonies (26 June and 10 August, respectively).^[3] Nikolaus Harnoncourt conjectured that Mozart composed the three symphonies as a unified work, pointing, among other things, to the fact that the Symphony No. 40, as the middle work, has no introduction (unlike No. 39) and does not have a finale of the scale of No. 41's.^[4]

The 40th symphony exists in two versions, differing primarily in that one includes parts for a pair of clarinets (with suitable adjustments made in the other wind parts). Most likely, the clarinet parts were added in a revised version.^[5] The autograph scores of both versions were acquired in the 1860s by Johannes Brahms, who later donated the manuscripts to the Gesellschaft der Musikfreunde in Vienna, where they reside today.^[6]

Premiere

As Neal Zaslaw has pointed out, writers on Mozart have often suggested – or even asserted – that Mozart never heard his 40th Symphony performed. Some commentators go further, suggesting that Mozart wrote the symphony (and its companions, Nos. 39 and 41) without even intending it to be performed, but rather for posterity, as (to use Alfred Einstein's words) an "appeal to eternity".^{[nb 2]}

Modern scholarship suggests that these conjectures are not correct. First, in a recently discovered 10 July 1802 letter by the musician Johann Wenzel (1762–1831) to the publisher Ambrosius Kühnel [de] in Leipzig, Wenzel refers to a performance of the symphony at the home of Baron Gottfried van Swieten with Mozart present, but the execution was so poor that the composer had to leave the room.^[7]^{[nb 3]}

There is strong circumstantial evidence for other, probably better, performances. On several occasions between the composition of the symphony and the composer's death, symphony concerts were given featuring Mozart's music for which copies of the program have survived, announcing a symphony unidentified by date or key. These include:^[8]

Dresden, 14 April 1789, during Mozart's Berlin journey
Leipzig, 12 May 1789, on the same trip
Frankfurt, 15 October 1790
Copies survive of a poster for a concert given by the Tonkünstler-Societät (Society of Musicians) 17 April 1791 in the Burgtheater in Vienna, conducted by Mozart's colleague Antonio Salieri. The first item on the program was billed as "A Grand Symphony composed by Herr Mozart".^{[nb 4]}

Most important is the fact that Mozart revised his symphony (see above). As Zaslaw says, this "demonstrates that [the symphony] was performed, for Mozart would hardly have gone to the trouble of adding the clarinets and rewriting the flutes and oboes to accommodate them, had he not had a specific performance in view."^[9] The orchestra for the 1791 Vienna concert included the clarinetist brothers Anton and Johann Nepomuk Stadler; which, as Zaslaw points out, limits the possibilities to just the 39th and 40th symphonies.^[9]

Zaslaw adds: "The version without clarinets must also have been performed, for the reorchestrated version of two passages in the slow movement, which exists in Mozart's hand, must have resulted from his having heard the work and discovered an aspect needing improvement."^[10]^{[nb 5]}

Regarding the concerts for which the Symphony was originally intended when it was composed in 1788, Otto Erich Deutsch suggests that Mozart was preparing to hold a series of three "Concerts in the Casino", in a new casino in the Spiegelgasse owned by Philipp Otto. Mozart even sent a pair of tickets for this series to his friend Michael Puchberg. But it seems impossible to determine whether the concert series was held, or was cancelled for lack of interest.^[3] Zaslaw suggests that only the first of the three concerts was actually held.^{[citation needed]}

Music

I. Molto allegro (8:13)

II. Andante (10:15)

III. Menuetto. Allegretto – Trio (4:32)

IV. Finale. Allegro assai (7:11)

Fulda Symphonic Orchestra, Simon Schindler conducting

The symphony is scored (in its revised version) for flute, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 2 horns, and strings.

The work is in four movements, in the usual arrangement for a classical-style symphony (fast movement, slow movement, minuet, fast movement):

Molto allegro, ²
₂
Andante, ⁶
₈
Menuetto. Allegretto – Trio, ³
₄
Finale. Allegro assai, ²
₂

I. Molto allegro

The first movement begins darkly, not with its first theme but with the accompaniment, played by the lower strings with divided violas. The technique of beginning a work with an accompaniment figure was later used by Mozart in his last piano concerto (KV. 595) and later became a favorite of the Romantics (examples include the openings of Mendelssohn's Violin Concerto and Sergei Rachmaninoff's Third Piano Concerto). The first theme is as follows.

$\relative c'' { \key g \minor \tempo "Molto allegro" \time 2/2 \set Staff.midiInstrument = #"violin" \set Score.tempoHideNote = ##t \tempo 2 = 105 \partial 4 es8(\p d) | d4 es8( d) d4 es8( d) | d4( bes') r bes8( a) | g4 g8( f) es4 es8( d) | c4 c }$

II. Andante

The second movement is a lyrical work in ⁶
₈ time. It is in the subdominant key of the relative major of G minor (B♭ major): E♭ major. The contrapuntal opening bars of this movement appear thus in keyboard reduction:

${ \new PianoStaff << \new Staff << \set Staff.midiInstrument = "string ensemble 1" \clef treble \key es \major \time 6/8 \tempo "Andante" \tempo 8 = 144 \new Voice \relative c' { \stemUp \partial 8 r8 r4. r8 r bes^( f')] f f] f[ f c^(] <f aes>)[ <f aes> <f aes>] <f aes>[ <f aes> <f aes>] <f aes>[ g16.^( bes32 aes16. c32] bes8) r es^( \break <b, b'>4_\> <c c'>8)\! r8 r es'^( <a,, a'>4 <bes bes'>8) r r <es es'> s <f aes!>^([ <es g>)] s <f aes>^([ <es g>)] <g bes>8^([ <fis a>16 <f aes> <e g> <es ges>] <d f>8) } \new voice \relative c' { \stemDown \partial 8 bes8(_\p es)[ es es] es[ es es] es[ es es] es[ es es] es_([ d c)] d4._\trill \grace { \stemDown c16_( d } es8)[ es_( f] g) r es \break r es[_. es]_. es[_. es_. es]_. r es_.[ es_.] es_.[ es_. es_.] d'32^( f) r16 bes,,4_\sf d'32^( f) r16 bes,,4_\sf bes4._\p bes8 } >> \new voice \new Staff << \set Staff.midiInstrument = "string ensemble 1" \clef bass \key g \minor \relative c, { \time 6/8 \partial 8 r8 <es es'> r r <g g'> r r <aes aes'>[ <a a'> <bes bes'>] <ces ces'>[ <bes bes'> <a a'>] <bes bes'>4. <bes, bes'> <es es'>8[ es' es] es[ es es] \break <aes,, aes'>[ es'' es] es[ es es] <g,, g'>[ es'' es] es[ es es] r <d, d'> <es es'> r <d d'> <es es'> <bes bes'>4. <bes bes'>8 } >> >> }$

III. Menuetto. Allegretto – Trio

The minuet begins with an angry, cross-accented hemiola rhythm and a pair of three-bar phrases, as shown in the following piano reduction:

${ \new PianoStaff << \new Staff << \set Staff.midiInstrument = "string ensemble 1" \clef treble \key g \minor \time 3/4 \tempo "Allegretto" \tempo 4 = 160 \new voice \relative c' { \partial 4 <d d'>4 <g g'>2 <bes~ bes'~>4 <bes bes'>4 <a a'>8[ <g g'>] \stemUp <fis fis'>[ <a a'>] <g g'>4 \stemNeutral <d d'> <g g'> <bes bes'>2 <d~ d'~>4 <d d'> <c c'>8[ <bes bes'>] <a a'>[ <c c'>] <bes bes'>4 <g g'> <d' d'> <g g'>2 <bes~ bes'~>4 \break <bes bes'> <a a'>8[ <f f'>] <e e'>[ <g g'>] <f f'>4 <e e'>8[ <d d'>] <cis cis'>[ <e e'>] <d d'>4 <c! c'!>8[ <bes bes'>] <a a'>[ <c c'>] <bes bes'>4 <bes e bes'>-. <a f' a>-. <gis b! gis'>-. <g cis g'>-. <f d' f>-. \stemUp e'^( g!) cis, d } \new Voice \relative c'' { s4 s2. s2 \stemDown d4 d s2 s2. s2. s2. s2. s2. s2. s2. s2. s2. <e, g bes>2 <g a>4 <f a> } >> \new voice \new Staff << \set Staff.midiInstrument = "string ensemble 1" \clef bass \key g \minor \relative c { \time 3/4 \partial 4 r4 <g g'> <bes bes'> <g g'> <d d'>2 <c c'>4 <bes bes'> r r <g' g'> <bes bes'> <g g'> <d d'>2 <fis d' fis>4 <g d' g> r r <es es'> <es' g> <d f> \stemUp e2 a4^~ a bes^\staccato g^\staccato f^\staccato g^\staccato d^\staccato \stemNeutral <g, d' g>-. <cis, cis'>-. <d d'>-. <e e'>-. <a, a'>-. <bes bes'>-. <g g'> <e e'> <a a'> <d d'> } \new Voice \relative c { s4 s2. s2. s2. s2. s2. s2. s2. \stemDown cis2. d4_. g,_. a_. bes_. e,_. fis_. } >> >> }$

Various commentators^[who?] have asserted that while the music is labeled "minuet", it would hardly be suitable for dancing. The contrasting gentle trio section, in G major, alternates the playing of the string section with that of the winds.

IV. Finale. Allegro assai

The fourth movement opens with a series of rapidly ascending notes outlining the tonic triad illustrating what is commonly referred to as the Mannheim rocket.

$\relative c' { \time 2/2 \tempo "Allegro assai" \key g \minor \set Staff.midiInstrument = #"violin" \set Score.tempoHideNote = ##t \tempo 2 = 120 \partial 4 d\p ( g ) bes-. d-. g-. bes2 ( a4 ) cis,8\f }$

A remarkable modulating passage in which every tone in the chromatic scale but one is played, strongly destabilizing the key, occurs at the beginning of the development section; the single note left out is G (the tonic):

$\relative c'' { \key g \minor \time 2/2 \set Staff.midiInstrument = #"violin" \set Score.tempoHideNote = ##t \tempo 2 = 120 \partial 4 bes\f( | d4) f-. a-. bes-. | des2( c4) e,-. | as4-. r b,-. r | r2 r4 r8 \times 2/3 { b16( c d } | es!4-.) r fis,-. r | bes!4-. r r2 | cis,4-. r r2 | f!4-. r gis,-. r | }$

Legacy

Reception

This work has elicited varying interpretations from critics. Robert Schumann regarded it as possessing "Grecian lightness and grace".^[11] Donald Tovey saw in it the character of opera buffa. Almost certainly, however, the most common perception today is that the symphony is tragic in tone and intensely emotional; for example, in The Classical Style, Charles Rosen calls the symphony "a work of passion, violence, and grief".^[12]

Although interpretations differ, the symphony is unquestionably one of Mozart's most greatly admired works,^[13] and it is frequently performed and recorded.

Influence

Ludwig van Beethoven knew the symphony well, copying out 29 bars from the score in one of his sketchbooks.^[14] As Gustav Nottebohm observed in 1887, the copied bars appear amid the sketches for Beethoven's Fifth Symphony, whose third movement begins with a pitch sequence similar to that of Mozart's finale (see example below).^[15]

$\relative c { \clef bass \key c \minor \time 3/4 \tempo "Allegro" \set Staff.midiInstrument = #"cello" \set Score.tempoHideNote = ##t \tempo 2. = 80 \partial 4 g(\pp | c ees g | c2 ees4 | d2 fis,4) | g2.~ | g2. }$

Franz Schubert likewise copied down the music of Mozart's minuet, and the minuet of his Fifth Symphony strongly evokes Mozart's.^[16] Zaslaw has suggested that a passage late in Joseph Haydn's oratorio The Seasons (1801), a meditation on death, quotes the second movement of the 40th Symphony and was included by Haydn as a memorial to his long-dead friend.^{[nb 6]}

The symphony has been widely recorded and adapted by many orchestras.^[17] Vince Guaraldi adapted the opening theme as a jazz piece in the song "Choro", from his 1965 studio album, "From All Sides".^{[citation needed]} Lebanese singer Fairuz also adapted the symphony for her 1972 song "Ya Ana Ya Ana".^{[citation needed]}

First recording

The first known recording of the 40th Symphony was issued by the Victor Talking Machine Company in 1915 under the title "Symphony in G Minor". The Victor Concert Orchestra performed under the direction of Victor's house conductor, Walter B. Rogers.^[18]

Notes

^ A possible exception is the so-called "Odense Symphony", whose attribution to Mozart is doubtful; see Mozart symphonies of spurious or doubtful authenticity.
^ For discussion of claims of this sort, see Zaslaw 1994; the quotation from Einstein is taken from this source.
^ The letter reads "im Wien habe ich selbst es von verstorbenem Mozart gehört, als Er sie bei Baron Wanswiten [sic] hat produciren lassen, das[s] er wärend der production aus dem Zimmer sich hat entfernen müssen, wie man Sie unrichtig aufgeführt hat", meaning "and in Vienna I have heard myself from the departed Mozart, that when he had it performed in Baron Wanswiten’s rooms, he had to leave the room during the performance because it was being played incorrectly."^[7]
^ The text of the poster is given in Deutsch 1965, p. 393.
^ Though quoted heavily above, Zaslaw is not alone in denigrating the old view that the symphony was never performed: Otto Biba 2009 writes, "Since there is no known date of a premiere performance, there developed the long standing legend among Mozart biographers of a romantic persuasion, who wished to portray primarily the brilliance and tragedy of a genius' life, that Mozart never heard performances of [his last] three symphonies. This arrogant assumption, which equates missing information with the theory that the event never happened, is not serious scholarship and must be rejected."
^ See No. 38, the aria "Erblicke hier, bethörter Mensch". Source: Zaslaw & Cowdery 1990, p. 210.

References

^ "Mozart – Symphony No. 40 in G minor". Classic FM. Retrieved 23 July 2020.
^ Heartz 2009, p. 207.
^ ^a ^b Deutsch 1965, p. 320
^ Clements, Andrew (23 July 2014). "Mozart: The Last Symphonies review – a thrilling journey through a tantalising new theory". The Guardian.
^ Zaslaw 1983, p. 10.
^ See Zaslaw 1983, p. 10, Swafford 1997, p. 287, and this facsimile edition.
^ ^a ^b Milada Jonášová [cs]: "Eine Aufführung der g-moll-Sinfonie KV 550 bei Baron van Swieten im Beisein Mozarts", in: Mozart Studien 20, Tutzing 2011, pp. 253–268. An abridged English translation was published in the Newsletter of the Mozart Society of America 16.1 (2012), (online).
^ List from Zaslaw 1983
^ ^a ^b Zaslaw 1983, p. 9
^ Zaslaw 1983, pp. 9–10.
^ James 1967, p. 33.
^ Rosen 1997, p. 334.
^ "The 20 greatest symphonies of all time". Classical Music/BBC Music Magazine. 25 September 2018.
^ Hopkins 1981.
^ Nottebohm 1887, p. 531.
^ Zaslaw & Cowdery 1990, p. 210.
^ Bowen, José Antonio (1996-01-01). "Tempo, duration, and flexibility: Techniques in the analysis of performance". Journal of Musicological Research. 16 (2): 111–156. doi:10.1080/01411899608574728. ISSN 0141-1896.
^ "Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart – Symphony in G Minor". Discography of American Historical Recordings.

Bibliography

Biba, Otto (2009). "Kommentar", Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart. Sinfonie g-moll, KV 550. Autographe Partitur. Erste und zweite Fassung. Faksimile-Ausgabe. Gesellschaft der Musikfreunde in Wien, p. 8.
Deutsch, Otto Erich (1965). Mozart: A Documentary Biography. Stanford, California: Stanford University Press.
Heartz, Daniel (2009). Mozart, Haydn and Early Beethoven, 1781–1802. New York: W. W. Norton. Extracts online at Google Books.
Hopkins, Antony (1981). The Nine Symphonies of Beethoven. Heineman.
James, Burnett (1967). An Adventure in Music. London: Baker. Retrieved 25 September 2016.
Nottebohm, Gustav (1887). Zweite Beethoviana. Leipzig: C. F. Peters. Available online Zweite Beethoveniana: at the International Music Score Library Project
Rosen, Charles (1997). The Classical Style: Haydn, Mozart, Beethoven (expanded ed.). New York and London: W. W. Norton. Online at Google Books.
Swafford, Jan (1997). Johannes Brahms: A Biography. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.
Zaslaw, Neal (1983). Introductory notes to a recording of the 31st and 40th Symphonies made by Christopher Hogwood and the Academy of Ancient Music, Oiseau-Lyre 410-197-2
Zaslaw, Neal (1994). "Mozart as Working Stiff". In James M. Morris (ed.). On Mozart. Washington: Woodrow Wilson Center Press.^{[page needed]}
Zaslaw, Neal; Cowdery, William (1990). The Compleat Mozart: A Guide to the Musical Works of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart. New York: W. W. Norton. Extracts cited at Google Books.

External links

Sinfonie in g K. 550 (1st version): Score and critical report (in German) in the Neue Mozart-Ausgabe
Sinfonie in g K. 550 (2nd version): Score in the Neue Mozart-Ausgabe
Symphony No. 40: Scores at the International Music Score Library Project
Kalmus miniature editions, from the William and Gayle Cook Music Library at the Indiana University Jacobs School of Music
A public domain version by the Columbia University Orchestra at TEOC Classical Music Radio: Symphony No. 40
The apartment where Mozart wrote his last three Symphonies: Michael Lorenz, "Mozart's Apartment on the Alsergrund"

[2] A possible exception is the so-called "Odense Symphony", whose attribution to Mozart is doubtful; see Mozart symphonies of spurious or doubtful authenticity.

[8] For discussion of claims of this sort, see Zaslaw 1994; the quotation from Einstein is taken from this source.

[10] The letter reads "im Wien habe ich selbst es von verstorbenem Mozart gehört, als Er sie bei Baron Wanswiten [sic] hat produciren lassen, das[s] er wärend der production aus dem Zimmer sich hat entfernen müssen, wie man Sie unrichtig aufgeführt hat", meaning "and in Vienna I have heard myself from the departed Mozart, that when he had it performed in Baron Wanswiten’s rooms, he had to leave the room during the performance because it was being played incorrectly."^[7]

[12] The text of the poster is given in Deutsch 1965, p. 393.

[15] Though quoted heavily above, Zaslaw is not alone in denigrating the old view that the symphony was never performed: Otto Biba 2009 writes, "Since there is no known date of a premiere performance, there developed the long standing legend among Mozart biographers of a romantic persuasion, who wished to portray primarily the brilliance and tragedy of a genius' life, that Mozart never heard performances of [his last] three symphonies. This arrogant assumption, which equates missing information with the theory that the event never happened, is not serious scholarship and must be rejected."

[22] See No. 38, the aria "Erblicke hier, bethörter Mensch". Source: Zaslaw & Cowdery 1990, p. 210.

[1] "Mozart – Symphony No. 40 in G minor". Classic FM. Retrieved 23 July 2020.

[FOOTNOTEHeartz2009207-3] Heartz 2009, p. 207.

[Deutsch-4] Deutsch 1965, p. 320

[5] Clements, Andrew (23 July 2014). "Mozart: The Last Symphonies review – a thrilling journey through a tantalising new theory". The Guardian.

[FOOTNOTEZaslaw198310-6] Zaslaw 1983, p. 10.

[7] See Zaslaw 1983, p. 10, Swafford 1997, p. 287, and this facsimile edition.

[Jonasova-9] Milada Jonášová [cs]: "Eine Aufführung der g-moll-Sinfonie KV 550 bei Baron van Swieten im Beisein Mozarts", in: Mozart Studien 20, Tutzing 2011, pp. 253–268. An abridged English translation was published in the Newsletter of the Mozart Society of America 16.1 (2012), (online).

[11] List from Zaslaw 1983

[Zaslaw_1983,_9-13] Zaslaw 1983, p. 9

[FOOTNOTEZaslaw19839–10-14] Zaslaw 1983, pp. 9–10.

[FOOTNOTEJames196733-16] James 1967, p. 33.

[FOOTNOTERosen1997334-17] Rosen 1997, p. 334.

[18] "The 20 greatest symphonies of all time". Classical Music/BBC Music Magazine. 25 September 2018.

[FOOTNOTEHopkins1981-19] Hopkins 1981.

[FOOTNOTENottebohm1887531-20] Nottebohm 1887, p. 531.

[FOOTNOTEZaslawCowdery1990210-21] Zaslaw & Cowdery 1990, p. 210.

[23] Bowen, José Antonio (1996-01-01). "Tempo, duration, and flexibility: Techniques in the analysis of performance". Journal of Musicological Research. 16 (2): 111–156. doi:10.1080/01411899608574728. ISSN 0141-1896.

[24] "Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart – Symphony in G Minor". Discography of American Historical Recordings.

[1]

[nb 1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[nb 2]

[7]

[nb 3]

[8]

[nb 4]

[9]

[10]

[nb 5]

[11]

[12]

[13]

[14]

[15]

[16]

[nb 6]

[17]

[18]

v t e Symphonies by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart
Unnumbered	K. 19a K. 45a (Old Lambach) K. 76^a K. 45b^a K. 74g^a K. 81^a K. 95^a K. 97^a K. 75^a K. 111+120 K. 96^a K. 161 K. 135+61h^a K. 196+121 K. 208+102 K. Anh. C 11.04^d K. Anh. C 11.18^d
Numbered	No. 1 (K. 16) No. 2 (K. 17)^b No. 3 (K. 18)^c No. 4 (K. 19) No. 5 (K. 22) No. 6 (K. 43) No. 7 (K. 45) No. 8 (K. 48) No. 9 (K. 73) No. 10 (K. 74) No. 11 (K. 84)^a No. 12 (K. 110) No. 13 (K. 112) No. 14 (K. 114) No. 15 (K. 124) No. 16 (K. 128) No. 17 (K. 129) No. 18 (K. 130) No. 19 (K. 132) No. 20 (K. 133) No. 21 (K. 134) No. 22 (K. 162) No. 23 (K. 181) No. 24 (K. 182) No. 25 (K. 183) No. 26 (K. 184) No. 27 (K. 199) No. 28 (K. 200) No. 29 (K. 201) No. 30 (K. 202) No. 31 (K. 297) (Paris) No. 32 (K. 318) No. 33 (K. 319) No. 34 (K. 338) No. 35 (K. 385) (Haffner) No. 36 (K. 425) (Linz) No. 37 (K. 444)^e No. 38 (K. 504) (Prague) No. 39 (K. 543) No. 40 (K. 550) No. 41 (K. 551) (Jupiter)
Adapted from serenades	K. 204 K. 250 K. 320
Lost	K. 19b K. 66c K. 66d K. 66e K. Anh. C 11.07 K. Anh. C 11.08
^a Symphonies of doubtful authenticity. ^b No. 2 now attributed to Leopold Mozart. ^c No. 3 now attributed to Carl Friedrich Abel (although Mozart changed the instrumentation). ^d Symphonies generally agreed to be spurious today, but included in either the old or new complete editions. ^e No. 37 now attributed to Michael Haydn, except for the slow introduction which Mozart added. List of symphonies by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart List of spurious/doubtful Mozart symphonies

Authority control databases
International	VIAF
National	Germany United States France BnF data Israel
Other	MusicBrainz work 2